Iowa
to be Paid in Case Alleging Monopoly Scheme
by Giant Prescription Drug Maker
States
and FTC alleged that Mylan Laboratories "cornered the market" on ingredients
and then raised the price of two key drugs by over 2000 percent.
DES
MOINES-- Attorney General Tom Miller announced Wednesday that
Iowa, other states and the Federal Trade Commission have settled in
principle a lawsuit that alleged a monopolization scheme led by Mylan
Laboratories of Pittsburgh PA.
"The
States and FTC alleged that Mylan developed an illegal plan late in
1997 to drastically increase prices on two generic drugs the company
makes," Miller said. "First, Mylan eliminated real and potential competitors
by cornering the market on the drugs' active ingredients. Then, in early
1998, Mylan raised the price of one drug by 2000 percent and the other
by 3000 percent," he said.
"We
alleged that Mylan's actions were illegal and unconscionable - all the
more so because some of the drugs are widely used to treat symptoms
of anxiety and frequently are needed by nursing home and hospice patients
and people with Alzheimer's disease," he said.
Miller
said settlement of the lawsuit, which was filed in December 1998, will
result in payments of $100 million to the states. He said preliminary
figures indicate that Iowa's portion may be about $1.6 million. The
suit was settled in principle Wednesday afternoon when the resolution
was approved by Mylan's board of directors. Final terms are expected
to be completed within several weeks, subject to approval by the State
Attorneys General, the FTC, and U.S. District Court Judge Thomas F.
Hogan. Thirty-three states are involved in the litigation.
Funds
going to the states will be used to benefit consumers and reimburse
the states' programs that paid inflated prices because of the alleged
price-fixing activity.
The
lawsuit alleged that Mylan Labs cornered the market on ingredients for
two drugs, clorazepate and lorazepam, by entering into long-term agreements
with suppliers and distributors so that only Mylan would have reliable
sources to obtain the active ingredients. Other defendants named in
the suit were Cambrex Corporation, a New Jersey maker and marketer of
specialized chemicals; Profarmaco, a wholly-owned Italian subsidiary
of Cambrex; and Gyma, a New York company that distributes pharmaceutical
compounds for Profarmaco and other manufactureres.
After
cutting off competitors' supply of key active ingredients for the drugs,
the suit alleged, Mylan raised the price of clorazepate more than 3000
percent in January 1998. The price jump translated to an increase from
about two cents per tablet to over 75 cents per tablet for clorazepate.
Two
months later, Mylan increased the price of lorazepam more than 2000
percent, or an increase from just over one cent per tablet to over 37
cents per tablet.
Together,
the two drugs are prescribed nationally about 20 million times per year.
The
suit alleged antitrust violations by Mylan including illegal restraint
of trade, monopolization, and conspiracy to monopolize the markets for
the two generic drugs.
"It
is illegal for companies to conspire to eliminate competitors and then
raise prices like this," Miller said.
"I
am especially pleased we were able to take this action in the area of
prescription drugs. High drug prices concern everyone, especially older
Iowans. While we can't guarantee lower prices, we will take action when
companies violate antitrust laws, because that hurts consumers, taxpayers
and companies that play by the rules."
-
30 -